How can a retail shoe store make money with the transition to VAT?
22.09.2026 7595

How can a retail shoe store make money with the transition to VAT?

So, changes to tax legislation have become a reality today. The VAT rate has increased from 20% to 22%. Effective 2026, the government has lowered the income limit for operating under the simplified tax system (STS) and patents. As a reminder, the income limit for the STS excluding VAT has been reduced from 60 million to 20 million rubles. Many footwear businesses that previously operated under the simplified tax system will transition to the new system this year, becoming VAT payers. Owners are faced with the question of how and where to cover additional costs. SR expert Evgeny Danchev, who specializes in increasing shoe retail sales, examines this challenging situation and offers recommendations on how to avoid losing profits. Given declining customer traffic in retail stores, rising taxes, and overall costs, the most effective way for a retail company to increase margins is to increase the trade markup, the expert believes.

Evgeny Danchev Evgeny Danchev -

business coach, consultant, expert in increasing sales of the fashion market. Author of the book "A Practical Guide to Increasing Sales of Shoes and Accessories". Author of sales scripts "60 responses to customer objections in a retail shoe store" and "Standards for retail shoe sales." Creator of an online school for fashion market leaders.

@evgenydanchev, https://onlineschool.wconsulting.su/



Look at your business's sales statistics and consider why you initially set your markup at a certain figure; why, for example, do you add a 150% or 200% markup to the cost of goods?

Ask yourself the following questions:

1. What are these trade margin figures based on? 

2. How does this trade margin take into account the company's increasing costs (marketing, rent, taxes, wages)?  

3. Can the trade margin be the same for several years, or should it change? 

4. How can the optimal trade margin level be determined for a retail business, and what criteria can be used to set it? 

A common limiting belief among managers is: “I can’t increase my retail prices by increasing my markup because my competitors will sell the product at a lower price and I will lose some of my customers and revenue.”

In fact, this phrase precisely explains the internal mechanism by which managers decide on retail pricing. Every business owner experiences two basic emotions during the process of setting it:

1. Fear

The owner fears losing revenue due to higher prices than the market average. For some reason, price becomes a more important criterion for managers during competitive analysis. They are terrified of the possibility of their product being sold at a higher price than similar or identical products from competitors.

Although price is only one selection criterion, what about service, sales associate performance, merchandising, bonus or discount programs, current promotions, and the company's overall market image?

I always have one important question for business owners: why, when they buy shoes at exhibitions, do they select them so carefully, trying on each model, evaluating its convenience, comfort, appearance, the materials from which it is made, but when it comes to sales and setting a trade markup, all these criteria fade into the background, and the price comes first, and it is always no higher than that of the competitors.

Over the past 12 years, I've worked as a business consultant with shoe retail chains in various countries (Russia, Moldova, Kazakhstan, Estonia, and Latvia), and we conducted competitive analysis for each business. This analysis yielded real statistics on the overlap between the client's product line and those of their main competitors. The share of identical products (exactly the same model or similar alternatives) was no more than 10%.

Therefore, when salespeople explain their failure to meet sales targets by retelling customer claims that competitors have the same models at lower prices, they must keep in mind the true percentage of similar products. They mustn't lower retail prices based on only a small percentage of such models.

There's nothing wrong with a small portion of your store's inventory being more expensive than your direct competitors. Why? I'll answer the same way I do when I look salespeople in the eye who constantly complain about high prices: if the prices on shoes and bags are always lower than the competition, then why even bother with salespeople on the sales floor? What added value will they provide to the customer? You could reduce your staff and leave one person in the store who will simply fetch the right size from the warehouse and run the receipt. And this person won't be a salesperson, just a cashier and stocker.

What's the difference between a salesperson and a cashier? A salesperson must use sales techniques, one of which is handling objections. Often, price objections arise for a simple reason: the salesperson doesn't know their product well. The customer, meanwhile, doesn't see the difference in the product and says, "Your price is too high." In essence, they're aleatherg for clarification on why they're paying 10-20% more than they would at the store next door.

And here the question isn't about the product's price, but rather what the seller knows about it and how they can present it. What competitive advantages does the product offer, what distinguishing features does it have, and what benefit does the customer receive by paying more at the checkout than at the store next door? This is how added value is created in the eyes of the customer.

Therefore, the fear of higher prices for goods than competitors is just fear and an excuse for sellers to protect themselves from their own incompetence.

1. Greed (in the good sense of the word) is the second emotion that influences the decision-making of managers regarding the formation of retail prices.

Businesses are created to generate profit, generate income, and therefore, "not selling too cheaply, or earning as much as possible" is what drives owners to invest their time and energy. Of course, everyone wants to buy cheap and sell expensive. But in practice, it doesn't always work that way.

Over the past few years, I've observed the following situation in some shoe businesses: at the start of the sales season, merchandise is offered at the first price, or with minimal discounts for loyalty cards. But sales plans are not met with this approach, inventory levels are slowly depleted, and store revenue is insufficient to cover the ordering of new collections. The owners explain the lack of promotions this way: "Why should I offer discounts or run promotions? The product is new and good; people should buy it even without discounts. I don't want to get customers used to discounts."

When the sales season arrives, cash flow gaps arise, cash is in dire need, and owners decide to sell off remaining inventory at steep discounts (up to 50%). As a result, customers still end up buying most of their collections on sale and at the maximum discounts.

For clarity, I ask the company for statistics on the collection's sales share by month (in pairs of shoes). For example, from September to December and from January to February. It happens that out of 100% of all pairs of shoes sold during these six months, 40% are sold from September to December, and 60% from January to February. Can this sales ratio be considered effective? More likely no than yes.

So, over four months, the company sells only 40% of its pairs for the fall-winter season at a high markup. And 60% of its pairs are sold at a low markup. Not a very effective strategy.

This is how healthy greed manifests itself in managers. They're unwilling to compromise, don't conduct marketing campaigns to stimulate sales, and then rush to sell off the product at a minimal markup, just to avoid having to keep it for the next season.

Having analyzed how two basic emotions work at the psychological level during the price formation stage, we can draw the following conclusion: the price of shoes and accessories can be formed according to two main principles.

The first is a low-price strategy that eliminates the need for a large number of sales assistants and added value. Under this strategy, only large discount chain stores can survive in the current market conditions. The 2026 tax law changes will have the least impact on them, as they are already VAT payers and operate with high turnover. A 2% VAT increase will have virtually no impact on their operations. The most significant threat to such businesses is not the tax changes, but rather the decline in store traffic. Discount stores must maintain high turnover; if it begins to decline sharply, increasing their markups will not prevent them from operating at a loss. A more appropriate strategy for this category of businesses would be to carefully optimize costs, including closing unprofitable stores and reducing staff.

The second principle of retail pricing is based on added value; accordingly, the level of service and merchandise in such stores is higher. Many businesses in this category will transition to the new tax system in 2026, becoming VAT payers (previously, they could operate under a simplified tax system).
And here, owners are faced with the question of how and where to cover additional costs. The answer can be found by analyzing two price elasticity curves of demand.

In the graph on the left, we see elastic demand, which means revenue increases as retail prices decrease. In the graph on the right, we see inelastic demand, which means revenue decreases as retail prices decrease.

When the Western model of end-of-season promotions and sales began to be widely adopted in Russia about 15 years ago, the graph on the left worked well. But in recent years, the graph on the right has increasingly worked well as well. Price reductions through discounts don't always lead to revenue growth. The explanation is simple: when a product's price is reduced due to a discount, the total receipt amount also decreases. This can only be offset by increasing the number of sales or increasing the complexity of the receipt (the number of items per receipt). And since all companies offer discounts, it's not always the case that more customers visit the store during a promotion or sale. If incoming traffic doesn't increase, it's possible that the store's revenue will even be lower than before the promotion. This doesn't mean promotions don't work or that they're unnecessary; it's just that to effectively implement them, a marketing campaign must be conducted in advance, in parallel with the sale, to inform potential buyers (in marketer parlance, "increase reach"). And this always entails additional marketing costs, which the company may not necessarily allocate.

A typical example comes from online business. In 2025, not all companies selling shoes and bags on marketplaces were profitable. The marketplaces themselves regulated retail prices, requiring suppliers to participate in promotions, sometimes lowering markups below 100% of cost. The increase in the number of purchases and turnover only led to higher logistics costs, marketplace commissions, and reduced sellers' margins. The result of this work was enormous disappointment among retailer managers in this sales channel and a trend toward developing their own online stores.

Given declining customer traffic in retail stores, rising taxes, and overall costs, the most effective way for a retail company to increase margins is by increasing its markup. Store traffic is declining not only in Russia, but also in Kazakhstan, Latvia, and Moldova. With declining traffic, increasing markups is the only way to generate more revenue and cover company costs. Additional costs should be passed on to customers rather than attempting to undercut competitors.

Why is the Central Bank of Russia reducing its key rate so slowly (in December 2025, it was reduced by only 0,5%)? Because the regulator understands that businesses will factor the VAT increase into retail prices, increasing trade margins. Fearing this, the Central Bank is taking a conservative approach to unfreezing inflation-control mechanisms.

To further support the argument that increasing trade margins is appropriate in the current market conditions, I'll share a case study from business practice. Analyzing the performance of a retail shoe chain for the spring-summer 2025 season, I saw a 26% year-on-year change in the average price per item (comparing 2024 and 2025). At the same time, total store revenue increased by 5%. The increase in the price per item was largely due to offering customers significantly smaller discounts at the end of the season than the previous year, and running promotions from the very beginning of the sales season. I'd like to emphasize the difference between discounts and promotions. At the end of the sales season, a direct discount on a product significantly reduces the trade margin and its price. A promotion at the beginning of the sales season (for example, a discount on only the second item on the receipt) doesn't significantly reduce the markup. Ultimately, a balance was achieved between the emotions of fear and greed, which allowed for a significant increase in the price per item.

What does this case study tell us? In 2025, customers were purchasing shoes at 26% higher prices than in 2024, yet the company's revenue didn't decline, but rather grew by 5%. Of course, the company didn't limit itself to simply reducing discounts. Changes were made to the management system and incentives for in-store salespeople, which, taken together, produced this result.

These data completely contradict conventional economic theory, which holds that higher retail prices lead to a decline in sales. In my experience, this isn't the first time an unconventional approach to sales has yielded results. It's essential to consider the global changes occurring in retail businesses' cost structures and respond to them promptly. Today, it's impossible to achieve positive sales results using yesterday's strategies. Managers need to change their approaches to understanding the financial and economic analysis of their businesses.

An increase in trade margins is inevitable. The exact amount to increase them should be determined on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the company's tax system. However, given inflation in Russia, a minimum increase of 5-7% is reasonable.

It's especially challenging right now for businesses that sell branded goods at recommended retail prices (RRPs). Low markups, limited marketing campaigns, and rising costs are hitting their owners hard. How can they grow and make money in these conditions?

In this situation, constructive dialogue is needed with the majority of sellers and the brand's supplier. A consolidated discussion on the markup, taking into account the growth of the taxable base, can be undertaken, and a position on increasing the RRP can be defended using facts and figures.

Also, if the franchise agreement does not provide for the sale of products from other suppliers, it is necessary to discuss permission to expand the product range with new, higher-margin products.


So, changes to tax legislation have become a reality today. The VAT rate has increased from 20% to 22%. Starting in 2026, the government has lowered the income limit for working under the simplified tax system...
5
1
Please rate the article

Materials on the topic

How to avoid over-purchasing goods?

How does the selection process typically work at an exhibition? A buyer walks into a manufacturer's or distributor's booth and begins selecting models based on design, price, and comfort. But how many buyers, starting their workday at an industry trade show, clearly…
20.10.2026 3621

What's really going on with retail managers?

The fashion labor market has its own unique characteristics. Industry experience has always been valued, and it continues to be an advantage for candidates today. Over the past few years, companies have been actively seeking people from major brands for leadership positions.
12.10.2026 4612

Effective methods that will help improve the effectiveness of sellers

Many store managers face the problem of staff burnout who work on the sales floor. Previous motivation schemes for salespeople - “salary +%” no longer work today, and therefore new ways are needed to interest employees...
30.10.2023 17508

How to open an effective store of shoes and accessories. Success formula

The language of the musician is notes, the language of the poet is words, and the language of the entrepreneur is numbers! But most small retail stores in Russia do not consider performance indicators, the only indicator that is taken into account by owners and managers is ...
20.06.2019 21061

Budget but attractive. How to get a store window right and bright with a limited budget

Speaking about trends in window dressing, we need to start with the fact that we are not aleatherg them, unfortunately. The trendsetters are Europe and the USA, and we are still seriously behind them in approaches to visual merchandising, not to mention the costs of it. By…
07.08.2018 36994
When you sign up, you will receive weekly news and articles about the shoe business on your e-mail.

To the beginning